Old Witch Soul | Dark Souls 2 Wiki

Does not *always* drop on NG+. SotFS, lastest update, did not drop on NG+ but I have had it drop in the past. Unsure as to why, if I had to guess it was to give the opportunity to get all the boss weapons

Which is pretty bull if you ask me. Now I gotta do a whole 3rd playthrough. Frustrating

Submit

How many souls are there which have seperate rewards from both soul traders?

Submit

i kill to ng+ the lost sinner

Submit

consuming gave me 25,000 not 60,000 coming man you got my hopes up with this.

Submit

So uhm... Can I play for the first time with a specific character and still obtain this by using Bonfire Ascetic? Don't I have to be in NG+?

Submit

Bonfire ascetic works!!!!! it does in sotfs so it should in the normal one too

Submit

it does not seem to work to bonfire ascetic for this soul, at least not in Scholar of the first sin.

Submit

the first time the lost sinner drops his soul, but the second time he drops a fragment of Izalith's soul, but remembering that her soul is in the lordvessel, how is that possible?

Submit

you can bonfire ascetic sinner for flame weapon

Submit

Worth it?

Submit

Can u just put in a bonfire ascetic instead???

Submit

If you haven't finished Lucatiel's quest yet, Sinner's Rise bonfire would be the best to Ascetic... After beating a boss 3x with Lucatiel surviving, talk to her in Aldia's keep and she'll give you her set + sword... And you also get the Old Witch Soul from the Lost Sinner, which you can trade for Chaos Blade and/or Flame Weapon. The Rotten is easier yes, but think of the Old Witch Soul = multi-benefit Ascetic. :)

Submit