Benhart of Jugo

benhartframe
General Info
icon hp souls Location Drops
?? 2,000 Majula Bluemoon Greatsword

Benhart of Jugo is an NPC in Dark Souls 2

 

 

Benhart of Jugo Information

  • NPC holding a BlueMoon Greatsword (Not to be confused with the real Moonlight Greatsword) in the path between Majula and the Shaded Woods. When you rescue Rosabeth of Melfia, he will thank you and become available for summons.
  • Teaches you the gesture Joy
  • Proud of his sword, a family heirloom, Benhart is convinced it has a powerful magic only a true swordsman can unlock. Unfortunately, it is a fake. Maughlin the Armourer will confirm this if you take the blade to him.
    • Regrettably, there is no additional dialogue or acknowledgment from Benhart if the player talks to him with the true Moonlight Greatsword.
  • Upon slaying Benhart, Merchant Hag Melentia will sell his armor.
  • If you summon Benhart for at least 3 of the boss fights that he can be summoned for, and he stays alive until the boss is defeated, afterwards while speaking to him in the Memory of Orro will award you with the following:
    • Moonlight Greatsword achievement
    • Bluemoon Greatsword
    • Benhart's Parma
    • Benhart's Set.
      • Note: The bosses do not have to be different ones, as a Bonfire Ascetic can be used to respawn the same boss repeatedly. 
      • Note that none of the final bosses in Throne of Want will count towards Benhart's questline/trophy, even though he can be summoned for them.

Encounters

Summon Locations

  • Brightstone Cove Tseldora. In a tent near the collapsed building containing the mimic at the Royal Army Campsite Bonfire. Assists with Prowling Magus boss fight.
  • King's Passage. To the left of the fog gate for Looking Glass Knight, who he can assist with.
  • Memory of Jeigh. Directly ahead the of player's spawn, down the steps leading to the shattered archway. Will only appear after the player has exhausted his dialogue in Memory of Orro.
  • Dragon's Rest. Near the fog gate to Elana, Squalid Queen. Benhart's survival in this fight will count towards the 3 fights he must survive in order to complete his questline/trophy.
  • Throne of Want. Next to the fog gate, where he can assist with all three back-to-back final boss fights. (None of these fights count towards Benhart's questline/trophy.)

Drops

  1. Bluemoon Greatsword

Dialogue

- When first encountered in the entrance to Shaded Woods

  1. Have you business with me?
    The way yonder's all blocked up you see. By this god-awful statue.
    Heavens above. Who thought it a good idea to put it there!
  2. Ohhhh, I'm in quite the pickle now.
    See that statue? Gives me the willies. Stare at it for long enough, it starts to look alive.
    Ach, It just does nae seem quite right. There are no craftsmen round these parts.
    Hey, you don't think a real-life person was turned to stone, do you?

- Talk after clearing the path to Shaded Woods

  1. What?! Clearing the way was your doing, was it?
    Haah, didn't think you had it in yer pal.
    No no no. That's not like it sounds, you know! It was a pleasant surprise, that's all.
    Name's Benhart. Thanks to you, I can resume my journey.
    If we share the same path, I'm sure that we are gonna meet again.
    I'll repay my debt to you in battle. And I swear it by my sword.
    The road ahead's gonna be long, but I'm here to help. Gah hah hah hah hah!
  2. I am in yer debt.
    It's a true man who honours his debts. And I'll see mine paid.
    I swear it, by my ancient sword.

- When first encountered in Drangleic Castle

  1. Ho! Well met, friend.
    Good to see you well. Yes, hehh hehh, very good indeed.
  2. I journeyed from the distant east to perfect my swordsmanship.
    Legend has it that powerful beings slumber in this land.
    This sword, it's been in my family for generations. And only a real man can wield it true.
    I may face any manner of man or beast, but none shall be a match for my sword. Heh heh heh heh…
  3. This land is a right mess, eh?
    King's gone, and the people have a mad glint in their eyes.
    The land itself is overrun by terrible beasts.
    No better place to test my sword, ey? Heh heh heh heh…

- When first encountered in Forest of the Fallen Giants

  1. Well, we meet again! What you doing here?
    Who'dve thought we'd meet in a place like this.
    Fate just won't let us stay apart, will she? Gah hah hah hah hah hah!
  2. See the old sword's caught your attention? Well, you've a good eye, then.
    Ah, it's been in my family for generations.
    They say it is crafted with moonlight, and we all know what that means, it wards off evil.
    And I would nae trade her for all the riches in the world.
    They say that no man has ever teased oot the sword's true power.
    But in the right hands…Heh heh heh heh heh heh…
  3. I see you've taken a liking to the sword. Well, I applaud you, for you've a sharp eye.
    But this is one sword pal that I will nae be giving up.
    If you still insist on having it…
    Then you will have to pry it from my cold hands! Gah hah hah hah hah hah!
  4. I've a great debt to you. And I'll never forget it.
    I, Benhart, swear by my honour, to aid you in your darkest hour! So nae problem pal.

- When first encountered in Memory of Orro

  1. Oh! Look at you! Old friend!
    I see yer travels weigh upon you yet.
    Just remember, I'm always ready to help.
  2. My homeland is in the far east. A kingdom of honourable fighting men.
    And this sword yet awaits a true man to wield it.
    I know how swords think, you see! Gah hah hah hah!

- When giving equipment to the player
We have outwitted death a good many times.
Huh huh, My dear friend, take these.

- When attacked but not aggroed
Ooph!
(or)
What in bloody…!
(or)
Enough with that!

 - When attacked and aggroed
Very well. I, Benhart, will be honoured to chop you to pieces.

- When killing the player
You knew this would happen…

- When re-encountered after aggroing
You're a sorry waste of life…

- When attacked and health is under 50%
Hey! How dare you!

- When killed
What's done…urgh… Is done…

- Unknown
A man's journey…is never done…

 

 

Trivia

  • The easiest method of obtaining his gear/achievement is widely debated, so multiple methods are mentioned here.
  • Summoning Benhart in Memory of Jeigh to fight the Giant Lord after talking with him in Memory of Orro is perhaps the easiest method to get his gear. To reset and allow another summon in Memory of Jeigh, use an ascetic on The Place Unbeknownst bonfire after killing the Giant Lord on the current intensity. The main issue with this method is that Benhart (and most NPC phantoms for that matter) tends to be incredibly stupid when trying to make him survive a fight (Lucatiel on ng+ Sinner...) , which is problematic in the Memory of Jeigh because of the constant fireballs, rolling statue head, and the damage the Giant Lord inflicts with his skyscraper-esque sword, but if Benhart survives to the end, it is undoubtedly the fastest method.
  • Dying can be used to reset the encounter should Benhart die before you are able to kill the boss. The Homeward Bone, Homeward Miracle, and the Aged Feather can all be used to reset the encounter should Benhart die. Returning you to your last visited bonfire in the process.
  • Alternatively, you can also use Bonfire Ascetics to reset the Prowling Magus and the Congregation boss fight three times to get the items. This is an easy fight where it is unlikely either you or Benhart will die. There is a bit of a distance between the boss and Benhart's summon sign, so the walking back and forth is the longest part. It is also advisable you clear out all the enemies leading from his sign to the boss fight before you summon him, just to be safe. Unfortunately, AI stupidity also comes into play here, as Benhart seems apt to fall off the ledge where the boulders come down, making this method, while easy if done well, incredibly annoying to watch your achievement walk off a ledge multiple times.
  • Bonfire Ascetics can also be used to fight the Looking Glass Knight multiple times. Be sure to equip the Red Eye Ring as the Looking Glass Knight will focus Benhart when he gets low health.
  • As with any NPC phantom, any combination of these methods will result in the desired effect, it just depends on what you believe to be the fight both you and Benhart can survive consistently with increasing difficulty. So long as you and Benhart complete 3 of any of these fights (or 2 of one and 1 of another, etc.) and he survives each, he will reward you with his gear and achievement if spoken to in the area behind the Pursuer fight.

 

NPCs
Alsanna, Silent Oracle  ♦  Ancient Dragon  ♦  Ashen Knight Boyd  ♦  Aslatiel of Mirrah  ♦  Bell Keeper  ♦  Blacksmith Lenigrast  ♦  Blue Sentinel Targray  ♦  Bowman Guthry  ♦  Cale the Cartographer  ♦  Captain Drummond  ♦  Carhillion of the Fold  ♦  Chancellor Wellager  ♦  Creighton the Wanderer  ♦  Crestfallen Saulden  ♦  Cromwell the Pardoner  ♦  Darkdiver Grandahl  ♦  Dyna and Tillo  ♦  Emerald Herald  ♦  Felicia the Brave  ♦  Felkin the Outcast  ♦  Grave Warden Agdayne  ♦  Head of Vengarl  ♦  Jester Thomas  ♦  Laddersmith Gilligan  ♦  Licia of Lindeldt  ♦  Lone Hunter Schmidt  ♦  Lonesome Gavlan  ♦  Lucatiel of Mirrah  ♦  Magerold of Lanafir  ♦  Manscorpion Tark  ♦  Masterless Glencour  ♦  Maughlin the Armourer  ♦  Melinda the Butcher  ♦  Merchant Hag Melentia  ♦  Merciless Roenna  ♦  Mild Mannered Pate  ♦  Milfanito  ♦  Milibeth  ♦  Nameless Usurper  ♦  Nashandra  ♦  NPC Dialogue  ♦  Peculiar Kindalur  ♦  Pilgrim Bellclaire  ♦  Rat King  ♦  Rhoy the Explorer  ♦  Rosabeth of Melfia  ♦  Royal Sorcerer Navlaan  ♦  Screenshots  ♦  Steady Hand McDuff  ♦  Stone Trader Chloanne  ♦  Straid of Olaphis  ♦  Strowen  ♦  Sweet Shalquoir  ♦  Titchy Gren  ♦  Vendrick  ♦  Vorgel the Sinner  ♦  Weaponsmith Ornifex



Tired of anon posting? Register!
    • Anonymous

      SotFS: summoning him for the throne watchers / nash COUNTS as a victory. I had 1 summon left to inherit his equipment and he gave it to me after the battle.

      • Anonymous

        Can u stop dying for 5 seconds? omg, completing his questline as a casters are the worst! redeye ring doesn't work & he hit like ****. Why npcs quest have to be tied to boss summon

        • Anonymous

          If you complited boss fighter and memories it is possible that Benhard will vanish from pursuer boss location. In that case go into memory of orro and talk to him there. You will receive his gear.

          • Anonymous

            Would have been neat if Scholar of the First Sin added extra dialogue for Benhart if you have the actual Moonlight Greatsword equipped when speaking to him. Wouldn’t contribute anything to the story, probably, but a neat thought nonetheless

            • Anonymous

              Its actually 100% cannon no lies telling the truth that this guy is ludwig the holy blade before he turned into a horse.

              Source - trust me

              • Anonymous

                I did Magnus looking glass knight and the king giant he’s in the memory but whenever I talk to him he repeats the same thing and does not give me the armour am I missing something ?

                • Anonymous

                  Magus is also convenient because you'll farm Titanite Slab in the process, and it's the easiest of the fights, so I don't see any downsides to this method.

                  • Anonymous

                    "Throne of Want. Next to the fog gate, where he can assist with all three back-to-back final boss fights. (None of these fights count towards Benhart's questline/trophy.)"

                    This is not true, I summoned him for Nashandra and it *did* count for his questline. I goofed and forgot to summon him for the Giant Lord, so he wouldn't give me his equipment in Memory of Orro (Yes, I exhausted his dialogue), but after summoning him for Nashandra and coming back to the memory, he did. I had already cleared Throne Watched and Defender before, and Benhart died against Aldia, so Nashandra was the only boss he assisted me with.

                    Wouldn't recommend though, she deals a ton of damage against NPCs since they don't dodge anything, so taking her down before Benhart died was a pretty close call. And you don't have an opportunity to send him away before Aldia shows up, so Aldia will have boosted health.

                    • Anonymous

                      "If you summon Benhart for at least 3 of the boss fights that he can be summoned for, and he stays alive until the boss is defeated, afterwards while speaking to him in the Memory of Orro will award you with the following: [sword, achievement,...]"

                      this is partially true, while you do need the three summons and wins, you don't need to talk to him in the memory to get the set, you don't need to talk to all of his locations either, you can simply speak to him once after unpetrifying the girl, do the three summons then talk to him at the castle where he'll be chilling right next to the bonfire

                      (in my case i only talked to him the first time at the Shaded woods entrance after killing Nashandra, did Prowling Magus and the Congregation 3 time then talked to him at the castle and i got the set + achievement)

                      • Anonymous

                        Benhart of Jugo an absolute unit the guy went to Drangleic just to freaking train he's not even undead as he still has memories of who he was where came from he even reached the throne of want on his own world as he left his summon sign there.

                        • Anonymous

                          Don't forget if you have the Name Engraved ring on his or any NPC summon sign for that matter will not show up. Just PSA, I'm not sure if I read that anywhere on here. It's a common sense thing but something you could totally forget about if you aren't paying attention. I know I and a friend were playing trying to get him the achievement and his sign wouldn't show up even after an ascetic was burned. Eventually we figured it out. Lol

                          • recommended method way I do it:
                            shaded woods, talk, brightstone cove, summon at tent first bonfire, defeat prowling magus. go back to first bonefire, use ascetic, summon him again, defeat prowling magus again.
                            drangleic central bonfire, talk, summon him just outside fog gate at king's pass, defeat looking glass knight.
                            fast forward, when you meet him at pursuer's stage at forest of fallen giants, he will give gears and achievement outside the dream.

                            good luck & godspeed

                            • Anonymous

                              has anyone else noticed the similarites between Benhart and Solaire? Knights of a forgotten land, wielding an ordinary sword they believe to be special, both are self made warriors whos strength comes from training, and both of them help you along your journey by allowing you to summon them and they are always in the oddest places.

                              • Anonymous

                                If you have summoned him for Prowling Magus, Elana and the Looking Glass Knight and talk to him while he is sitting after the Pursuer arena (not inside the memory), he will already give you his equipment. You don't have to talk to him inside the memory for that.

                                • Anonymous

                                  Summoned Benhart for Prowling Magus fight 3x (used bonfire ascetic). Didn’t have to progress to memory or Orro to get the achievement and equipment, Benhart was sitting right after Twin Dragonriders fight in Dragleic Castle

                                  • I talked to him at the Pursuer arena before summoning him three times, after that i summoned him to fight Elana, but when i went back to the Forest of Fallen Giants to gte the sword he wasn't there. He didn't die during the bossfight so where the hell is he?

                                    • Anonymous

                                      Is it me or are all enemies hardier after an ascetic in Majula? Suddenly upon return of previously cleared areas, the mobs are like twice the aggro and hp

                                      • Anonymous

                                        So wait you mean to ****ing tell me this achievement is locked behind co op that requires me summon him for giant lord or ****ING ELANA?

                                        Message: "I can't take this"

                                        • This madlad survived every boss we did together on a magic pixel of health and I mean all, the giant lord, the magnus, the looking glass even the queen in sunken king

                                          hes got acctual magic in that sword i swear

                                          (sadly he did not survie aldia but he did beat nat) though as they dont count for his quest it dont matter
                                          also if you want 2 of his sword do sunken king before drangelic then you'll meet him after the pursuer area and get his gear, then you can kill him in the memory for a 2nd one

                                          • Anonymous

                                            A money obsessed merchant see a potentially legendary sword and says it's a fake and that stands as a confirmation... Lol

                                            • Anonymous

                                              If you don't care about his storyline or achievement, and you only want his gear, just go ahead and kill him, this quest a serious PITA

                                              • "DLC bosses do not appear to add to this count"? i'm pretty sure he give me his equipment after he survived magus, mirror knight and elana

                                                • Anonymous

                                                  A really simple way to get this gear is to just Murder him. Ruthlessly, with Chain Backstabs, at SL1 with a dagger.

                                                  • Anonymous

                                                    DLC bosses are accounted for the trophy. I summoned him twice on Looking Glass Knight, and once in Elana, and I got his equipment before I hit Memory of Orro.

                                                    • Anonymous

                                                      I summoned him for prowling magus, looking glass knight, and watcher and defender, but hes still not giving me his set. Did I do something wrong?

                                                      • "DLC bosses do not appear to add to this count." This is incorrect. I summoned him for the Squalid Queen as my third fight with him and he finally coughed up his gear. The other two fights were the Looking Glass Knight and the Prowling Magus. The Squalid Queen was definitely the hardest one to keep him alive. When she summoned her golden friend, I had to agro him away from her and the NPC summons to keep him from clubbing them to death while they wailed on her. This worked for a while till Queenie decided to teleport next to me which brought everyone together in a giant mess of attacks. This is what usually kills off Ellie, but Benhart was usually better about getting out of the way. Even so, Golden boy finally went down with Queenie having very little health left. At that point it was a race to kill her before Benhart died (who wasn't looking too good). When I dropped her, Benhart had about 2 pixels of health left on his HP bar.

                                                        • Anonymous

                                                          If he gave you his items, can you still summon him for the Giant Lord? Since I need him to tank the aggro of the giant to farm him.

                                                          • Anonymous

                                                            correction,you only need 2 bosses in SOFTS,i only summoned him for freja and mirror and he was behind pursuer's boss room

                                                            • Anonymous

                                                              Will he appear after the pursuer arena before you get the ashen mist heart? And if so can you get his gear there?

                                                              • Anonymous

                                                                for some reason even tho i finished his dialogue both outside the shaded woods and inside drangliec castle and im human he isnt showing up for sommon against the looking glass knight.

                                                                • Anonymous

                                                                  Only had 2 bosses with him, forgot to take him for the giant lord used him for a dlc boss then went back to the memory of Orro and he gave me his gear

                                                                  • Anonymous

                                                                    ive just tested it, it turns out throne watcher/defender doesnt count sucks because now i have to go on newgame++ to get the achiev was hoping to get it on newgame+ so i wouldnt bother on newgame++ since now i only need chancelor spells and thatll be 100% darksouls achievements steam name : potatototo

                                                                    • Anonymous

                                                                      He seems like the guy, that is only here for the fun and adventure, but then he gives you the sword, his most valuable possession, and chooses to rest for all eternity inside a fading memory. I'm actually interested in his story now.

                                                                      • Anonymous

                                                                        What if I already killed with him three bosses and he survived all encounters, but then I summoned him for another boss (Elana, Squalid Queen from DLC) and he died ? (I died with him) Will I get his gear ? >_>

                                                                        • Anonymous

                                                                          I wonder how many people have actually asked how Benhart got in the memory of Orro in the first place and also wondered if the statues in the Pursuer Boss fight look strangely similar to Benhart... Probably just coincidences but still something to think about.

                                                                          • Anonymous

                                                                            Well, another weird one. Did three bosses with him but He won't Hand over his gear... Just Sits in Orros memory and Talks About his Sword... Will He give it After completing the memory?

                                                                            • Anonymous

                                                                              I haven't gotten to the memory of Orro yet. I've spoken with him at all the other locations, yet for some reason, I cannot summon him anywhere. I am human. Can anyone think of a reason he just won't show up?

                                                                              • Anonymous

                                                                                Can anyone tell me if I can ummon him ifI kill him?
                                                                                Already didit and talkedwithhis ghoat and he told me to protect me butI'm still insecure

                                                                                • Anonymous

                                                                                  I guess he doesn't say anything when you roll up with the real Moonlight Greatsword and do all of its special moves.

                                                                                  • Anonymous

                                                                                    I think FROM meant this character to be named BeRnhart. And not Be-nhart. Probably another lost in translation case.

                                                                                    • Anonymous

                                                                                      I summoned him once for the magus and congregation boss fight without getting to the boss and died. His summon sign is no longer there, will it respawn?

                                                                                      • Anonymous

                                                                                        what are those poison hand monsters inside the chamber. Just down the path some of them wield skeleton weapons of some kind. what in the world are those things?

                                                                                        • Anonymous

                                                                                          I summoned this guy for the watcher & defender but he died as I finished it... Would this count as a death for him even though this fight does not count towards his quest line? At this point I had 2/3 fights done with him and assumed it wouldn't matter if he died, only that he survived Nash or any other boss

                                                                                        Load more
                                                                                        ⇈ ⇈